Framework · Leadership & Management
The 1‑on‑1 Framework
A nine-grid model for structuring meaningful one-on-one discussions. Three content categories × three perspectives — covering what to discuss, from whose angle, and when each combination matters most.
Too long; did read
- • 1-on-1s serve three purposes: managing operational challenges, tracking personal engagement and wellbeing, and supporting development.
- • Each purpose can be approached from three angles: manager support ("Me"), coaching ("You"), and team questions ("Us").
- • This creates a 3×3 grid of nine conversation spaces — you don't cover all nine every time, but every box should be visited over time.
- • Your organizational rhythm defines when and how often 1-on-1s happen — they must "fit the beat."
- • The worst misconception: that it's solely the manager's job to make them work. It takes two adults.
Core Principles
1-on-1s must fit the beat
Your organizational practices define the rhythm for your 1-on-1s, not vice versa. Once you've defined your vision, purpose, values, and 'beat', you can map out one-on-ones that fit inside the system.
It takes two adults
The worst misconception of running successful 1-on-1s is that the manager's sole responsibility is to make them work. Leadership belongs to everyone — both participants must care about being in the meeting.
Caring cannot be substituted
AI coaches and tools can augment capability, but they won't substitute the underlying need for leaders and people around you to care about your personal development. If tools are used to escape that need, they're being misused.
Culture shapes content
Based on the culture you've created, your 1-on-1s may need zero corrective performance management, or it may become the only forum where performance is managed. The former guarantees a healthier dynamic.
Hire people you'd coach after parting ways
Done right, you enable your people to leave — and doing it perfectly means you treat them in a way they don't want to. Hire people you're willing to develop even after you can no longer work together.
"Marry someone you can be friends with even after divorce. You should hire people you're willing to develop after you have to part ways with them."
The Nine-Grid
Select a row (what to discuss) and a column (from whose perspective) to explore example questions.
Content category (rows)
Perspective (columns)
Operational Challenges × Manager Support
The manager's responsibility to offer help. Your behaviour as a manager may cause many issues — something you should constantly be mindful of.
Example questions
- "What can I unblock for you this week?"
- "Are there decisions waiting on me that are slowing you down?"
Two Anchor Questions
Regardless of your system, these two questions from The Coaching Habit bookend every meaningful 1-on-1.
Opening
"What's on your mind today?"
Centers people around the moment by allowing them to dump whatever is on their mind right now.
Closing
"What was the most valuable thing in our discussion?"
Leaves the other person with a sense of value created, and helps you follow up with more of what works.
Does this resonate?
Would love to hear why — what landed, what didn't, what it stirred up in your own work.
Share your storyUnlock more
Don't miss future writing — become a paid Substack supporter and keep this going.
Become a supporter